axis-java-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Martin Gainty <>
Subject Re: Patches
Date Tue, 02 May 2017 12:54:18 GMT

From: Andreas Veithen <>
Sent: Monday, May 1, 2017 5:43 PM
To: java-dev
Subject: Re: Patches

Is this the list of all open issues which have an attached patch, or
is this a specific list of patches that you would like to see applied?
I'm asking this because a lot of proposed patches lack unit tests,
don't address the issue in the right way or have other problems.


On Thu, Apr 20, 2017 at 11:18 AM, Dennis Kieselhorst <> wrote:
>> Do you have a list of issues?
> Sure:
> AXIS2-4086, AXIS2-3964, AXIS2-4184, AXIS2-4947, AXIS2-5524, AXIS2-5628, AXIS2-2702, AXIS2-5477,
AXIS2-5522, AXIS2-5391, AXIS2-5132, AXIS2-5150, AXIS2-5152, AXIS2-4882, AXIS2-4725, AXIS2-5533,
AXIS2-5245, AXIS2-5762, AXIS2-3635, AXIS2-3322, AXIS2-4542, AXIS2-4246, AXIS2-5536, AXIS2-3796,
AXIS2-5040, AXIS2-3623, AXIS2-5428, AXIS2-5483, AXIS2-5793, AXIS2-5532, AXIS2-5414, AXIS2-5049,
AXIS2-5794, AXIS2-5510, AXIS2-3559, AXIS2-5129, AXIS2-5023, AXIS2-5624, AXIS2-4003, AXIS2-5534,
AXIS2-4957, AXIS2-5674, AXIS2-5208, AXIS2-5486, AXIS2-4608, AXIS2-5482, AXIS2-5697, AXIS2-4328,
AXIS2-5647, AXIS2-5016, AXIS2-5172, AXIS2-5080, AXIS2-4504, AXIS2-4222, AXIS2-5671, AXIS2-4462,
AXIS2-4993, AXIS2-5039, AXIS2-5392, AXIS2-4756, AXIS2-5550, AXIS2-5668, AXIS2-5001, AXIS2-5676,
AXIS2-5206, AXIS2-4333, AXIS2-5586, AXIS2-4996, AXIS2-5267, AXIS2-5680, AXIS2-5498, AXIS2-5587,
AXIS2-5463, AXIS2-5401, AXIS2-5523, AXIS2-4091, AXIS2-4064, AXIS2-3278, AXIS2-5285, AXIS2-4056,
AXIS2-5474, AXIS2-5476, AXIS2-5707
> Regards
> Dennis
MG>for example AXIS2-3278 posted in 07 (last commented by Sagara)

When setting the value useOriginalwsdl to true in a services.xml and not providing a wsdl
file in your directory the following message occurs:

Unable to generate WSDL 1.1 for this service If you wish Axis2 to automatically generate the
WSDL 1.1, then please +set useOriginalwsdl as false in your services.xml

Proposed Solution with Patch:
However, it would be better if a customizable error message (including a blank message) could
be returned or even better allow the behavior to return different http error codes like 404
where the wsdl is effectively hidden without giving a clue that it exists.

MG>In 2012 Sagara mentions " we have lived with existing approach for a long time and we
need to know what other users think about this. Can you send a mail to both dev and user list
with your suggestion ?"

MG>in other words since the user-community is used to receiving a specific error message:
"Unable to generate WSDL 1.1 for this serviceIf you wish Axis2 to automatically generate the
WSDL 1.1, then please +set useOriginalwsdl as false in your services.xml"

MG>rather than returning 404 for missing wsdl

MG>Since its been 5 years since anyone worked on this could either Sagara or Andreas close
this out as wont-fix?

> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail:
> For additional commands, e-mail:

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message