calcite-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Francis Chuang <>
Subject Re: Mirroring JIRA/GitHub comments
Date Wed, 05 Dec 2018 02:50:46 GMT
There is the possibility to turn off notification emails for comments, 
PR reviews and PR pushes:

Unfortunately, the settings are on a global basis and it's not possible 
to turn them off for specific repositories.

On 5/12/2018 1:37 pm, Michael Mior wrote:
> If GH comments are mirrored to JIRA, it does mean that there would be
> duplicate emails if you're subscribed to both the PR on GH and the JIRA
> case. It does mean though that there would be one place where you could see
> all comments. Definitely this should only be enabled if the majority thinks
> it will be more productive. If it makes things worse, especially for those
> who invest much more time than I such as Julian, then I would revoke this
> suggestion.
> --
> Michael Mior
> Le mar. 4 déc. 2018 à 20:00, Julian Hyde <> a écrit :
>> I suspect that my practices are out of step with Michael's practices
>> (and maybe other people's too). I prefer to work in JIRA as much as
>> possible, using git's review mechanism only for critiques of
>> individual lines. I do this because I like being able to see how a
>> contribution evolved, and the reasoning behind it, long after that
>> contribution has been merged. Github is not very good at preserving
>> that stuff.
>> Mirroring is all very well, but will it double the volume of email traffic?
>> I'm feeling rather burned out because I committed over 50 of other
>> people's PRs last release.
>> Julian
>> On Tue, Dec 4, 2018 at 3:02 PM Francis Chuang <>
>> wrote:
>>> Thanks for taking this on, Michael!
>>> I think this is a good idea as having to go back and forth between a
>>> Github PR and JIRA issue can sometimes be a massive context switch. I
>>> think Github comments are current mirrored into the appropriate JIRA
>>> issue, but the reverse does not currently work.
>>> If possible, I think this would also be a good idea for the
>>> calcite-avatica and calcite-avatica-go repositories as well.
>>> On 5/12/2018 6:56 am, Michael Mior wrote:
>>>> This discussion came up a while back, but I think it would be really
>>>> helpful to have JIRA comments mirror to the association GitHub issue.
>> When
>>>> reviewing PRs, I start by looking for those with no comments
>> (indicating
>>>> someone else has already had a look). Then I have to dig up the JIRA
>> case
>>>> and check if someone has reviewed there. If there are no objections,
>> I'll
>>>> file a ticket with INFRA.
>>>> --
>>>> Michael Mior

View raw message