velocity-user mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "Manish" <>
Subject Conditional display - Approach question
Date Wed, 20 Oct 2004 04:46:08 GMT
This is not a strictly Velocity question, but putting it here because I
believe that I'd be able to get good inputs here.

I use Velocity as view, and struts for actions. Now I have several actions
which search DB for various searches and produce a list.
I have single velocity template "results' to which all these actions are

Now let's say I have a list of books which can be searched on various
parameters and various actions are defined for these searches. Now I need to
display only those books which satisfy condition - isAvailable (actual list
and condition is far more complex) and not otherwise. I have 2 approaches -

(1) Put a conditional check in velocity template while iterating though a
list to decide if the book should be displayed. It would be sth like this -

#foreach($book in booklist)
         ## do whatever here...
    ## don't display anything if book is not available

(2) Another approach is to check this in VARIOUS actions while creating the
list itself if the book should be added to the list at all.

First approach sounds easier to implement, but it means that the view part
is taking decision about business logic, which sounds "not so nice"
Second approach is difficult because there are many actions that will have
to be changed, besides there are many programmers working on various
actions, so they all need to take care of that. So I am trying to avoid
this.... However, there's one more advantage here, if I do it this way I can
add a unit test to check that only "available" books are getting added.

What should be the best approach in this case, it's not just about getting
this done somehow.
I'd highly appreciate any inputs here.

- Manish

p.s. BTW, is there anything similar to Java "continue" in VTL?

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message