cocoon-users mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Gabriel Gruber <>
Subject Re: from Cforms to Wicket
Date Fri, 01 Mar 2013 13:47:43 GMT
Hey Mika,

I would suggest to use Vaadin ( for your dynamic form 
It is pure java and css and all the client stuff is done via a small GWT 
integration into cocoon is easy... we have done it to build a new app on 
top of our existing hibernate+spring+cocoon webapp.


From:   Mika M Lehtonen <>
Date:   18.02.2013 15:10
Subject:        Re: from Cforms to Wicket

but as I started this chain, I stated that my problem is to "convert" my 
own defined dynamic XML into HTML4 (or HTML5) forms. I was looking 
something to replace Cforms (not just plain XSLT). I am also considering 
to move to C3 because as I stated earlier, developing without tools is 
hard. If I could take e.g. NetBeans and continue with that, I would be 
better off in the long run.

I was considering Apache Wickets because some integration has been done 
with C3, but right now it doesn't seem to be a real option.

HTML5 is still hype from my point of view.

- mika -

18.2.2013 15:50, gelo1234 kirjoitti:
HTML5 in its basics is a superset of HTML4. If you don't use 
HTML5-specific tags/spec you go well with old good HTML4.

The original issue was NOT whether to use HTML5 or old HTML, but whether 
to use CForms or just raw XHTML/HTML (4 or 5) forms.

If you like to have HTML5 goodies in browsers that support it, just use 
e.g. Cocoon Actions in Sitemap OR Advanced Sitemap Matchers OR in 
REST-Controller by inspecting HTTP Headers return different Page that 
generate a different Content (with XSLT) for IE8.


2013/2/18 Mika M Lehtonen <>
Also HTML5 support for IE seems to be weak, even for IE9. There are still 
lot of people using IE8 or even older browser + lot of people in some sort 
of governmental offices using their own versions..
We can't sell apps without IE-support, absolutely no way.

- mika -

18.2.2013 14:45, Robby Pelssers kirjoitti: 

The only thing I wonder about is...

Cocoon and neither XSLT2.0 support html5 serialization for all I know.  So 
does someone using Cocoon already generate HTML5 content with Cocoon and 
how did you accomplish this.


-----Original Message-----
From: Mika M Lehtonen []
Sent: Monday, February 18, 2013 1:42 PM
Subject: Re: from Cforms to Wicket

thanks for your efforts. HTML5 it is, with or without C3.

- mika -

18.2.2013 14:25, Francesco Chicchiriccò kirjoitti:
On 18/02/2013 13:09, Mika M Lehtonen wrote:
I know what you mean. Most of the Xforms sites are dated back to 2002
or 2003.. Sounds like a standard having glorious future behind..

This betterForm still sounded proper for my purposes because it
actually implements server-side approache of Xforms. So I could use
Xforms definition for producing HTML-forms, if I understood right. It
actually resembles a lot of Cforms with a difference that it seems to
be under development taking contemporary challenges into account.
"under development" with latest release 4.1 dating 1 year back [1]

But would I still need C3 (or C2.11 / C2.2)?
It depends on you, and on how much effort do you want to put on this
Anyway, not necessarily, even though Cocoon will help in you in the
XML side if the job.

I would like to get familiar with C3 if I only could figure out how
to start.

The biggest problem with C2.11, IMHO, was not having proper
development tools to use. I ended up writing files with Notepad++.
And I never realized how to do debugging..

18.2.2013 10:48, Francesco Chicchiriccò kirjoitti:
On 17/02/2013 21:57, Mika M Lehtonen wrote:
How about some XForms implementation like this
Sounds promising..
I personally wouldn't bet much on XForms...


To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message